Which specific metrics do you prioritize to measure marketing effectiveness, and why?
Answers split between brand-focused metrics, engagement and discussion quality, financial outcomes, and direct response measures like clicks and CTR, reflecting varied priorities for assessing marketing effectiveness.
8 answers
Answers


Amanda Natividad
Chief Evangelist · Sparktoro
Quality of Discussions
Amanda Natividad says she likes to use quality of discussions as a metric, because engaging comments and questions suggest content is hitting right, while no replies signals something is off.
The answer starts at 18:51.
The Marketing Millennials · Listen on Apple Podcasts

Peter Giorgi
SVP of Brand Marketing, Partnerships and Creative Excellence · Rocket
Awareness, Affinity, Action, Advocacy
Peter Giorgi says marketing for him is about awareness, affinity, action and advocacy—whether more people know the brand, feel differently, tell friends and take meaningful action—and says brand health measures matter.
The answer starts at 21:00.
The Marketing Millennials · Listen on Apple Podcasts

Vineet Mehra
(NASDAQ: CHYM) Chief Marketing Officer (IPO June’25) · Chime
LTV to CAC
Vineet Mehra says he focuses on LTV to CAC, fully loading customer acquisition costs, to ensure the right payback profile and unit economics on every dollar spent to drive growth.
The answer starts at 17:58.
Uncensored CMO · Listen on Apple Podcasts

Louisa Frahm
SEO Director · ESPN
Clicks and Traffic
Louisa Frahm says clicks and accumulated traffic over time were the primary performance metrics, though she notes click-through rates are down and clicks alone can't evaluate search performance.
WTF is SEO? · WTF is SEO? · Read
Marc S. Pritchard
Chief Brand Officer · Procter & Gamble
Market Growth & Share
Marc S. Pritchard says he measures marketing effectiveness by whether the brand is growing the market, market share, users, sales and profit, calling it the "five fecta." He frames this as marketing driving growth and creating value.
WARC · Watch on YouTube

Amanda Cole
Chief Marketing Officer · Bloomreach
Revenue
Amanda Cole says she always goes back to revenue, calling it the most important number and the one marketing should care most about, since it comes from new and existing customers and keeping customers.
The Marketing Millennials · The Marketing Millennials · Listen at 31:38

Naomi West
Senior Product Marketing Manager · Customer.Io
Click‑Through Rate
Naomi West prioritizes click-through rate for emails with a call to action, saying it's great when you want the subscriber to take an action. She notes emails without a CTA can't measure that.
The Marketing Millennials · The Marketing Millennials · Listen at 37:54

Adam Holmgren
Co-founder & CEO · Fibbler
CTR
Adam Holmgren says CTR is partly what he evaluates engagement on — it depends on your objectives, but he calls it a good metric to compare campaigns against each other.
N/A · N/A · Listen at 44:55
More Marketing questions
View all →- What practices keep marketing teams aligned in fast-changing environments?15 answers
- How should marketers adapt for AI-driven search engines?11 answers
- What storytelling aspect matters most in crowded markets?7 answers
- Which business outcome should marketers prioritize over engagement metrics?8 answers
- Which human skill is key to succeed with AI in marketing?12 answers


















