Emotional ads take the lead as AI rewrites measurement

The gist

Emotional, creative ads are now the main growth lever as AI-powered measurement exposes just how forgettable nearly half of campaigns really are.

What to know

  • System1’s 2026 report revealed 48% of ad viewers feel nothing, making ad dullness a measurable—and fixable—growth killer.
  • Marketers are ditching old attribution models in favor of AI-driven testing platforms, with over half investing in AI to predict emotional impact before ads even launch.
  • System1’s late-2026 Christmas leaderboard crowned emotionally-charged work—Morrisons, Sainsbury’s, M&S, Aldi, Disney, and more—at the maximum 5.9-star rating.

Dullness Becomes Diagnosable

In late 2026, new research and industry debate reframed ad dullness as a measurable, fixable barrier to growth, with early creative signals regaining importance over last-click metrics.

By late October 2026, the evidence base around ineffective creative had become newly concrete and newly public. Marketing Architects’ “Nerd Alert: The Cure for Dull Advertising” unpacked System1’s 2026 report “The Cure for Dull,” which framed the industry’s problem in emotional terms, saying it “reveal[s] why 48% of ad viewers still feel absolutely nothing” and setting out “the five creative ingredients” meant to correct that failure, turning dullness from a vague complaint into a measurable barrier to growth.

Days later, the measurement side of the market reinforced that shift from another angle: ad effectiveness was again being discussed in predictive, forward-looking terms rather than only post-sale attribution. In Marketing Architects’ October 27 analysis, Anthony Jones said, “Up until about the mid 2000s, so 2007, 2008… people have stopped using it… And I think that as the industry has moved more and more of its focus on the last click, the last sale, the ad awareness metric has become less relevant in some people's minds,” underscoring a late-2026 reappraisal of early signals tied to future commercial outcomes.

Sources
The Marketing ArchitectsWARC

AI Transforms Creative Valuation

AI-powered platforms are shifting creative evaluation from outdated visibility metrics to rigorous, investment-minded frameworks that demand multiple models and third-party validation.

Why measurement shifted is that marketers increasingly saw older systems optimizing the wrong thing: as the August 27, 2026 analysis put it, measurement moved from visibility to accountability to optimization, until “what could be observed became what counted.” That critique matters because it reframed creative assessment as an investment problem rather than a reporting problem; using the Arthur Eddington ocean-net story, the same analysis warned that “the net with a two inch mesh… it really… [is] not the point,” adding, “We build a very good net and then we publish the catch as the census and, and is ultimately our proof point.”

Against that backdrop, the October 27, 2026 how-to argued that AI gives marketers a way to evaluate creative more rigorously before defaulting to blunt attribution proxies, saying “AI has the potential to fundamentally change what we're able to understand about marketing effectiveness” and can “dramatically expand that capacity.” The practical shift is toward triangulation and investment discipline: marketers are advised to use multiple models and third parties rather than “that one metric you've been stuck on for too long,” while more than half of buy-side respondents said they were investing in scaling AI for advanced measuring frameworks to reduce existing gaps.

Sources
Sleeping Barber - A Marketing PodcastThe Marketing Architects

Storytelling Outranks Media Spend

Strong narrative, humor, and memorable characters drive ad effectiveness far more than targeting or budget, with creativity emerging as the top lever for profitability.

The case for emotional creative starts with a simple limit on media power: as Marketing Architects puts it, “you can't media buy your way out of a boring idea.” Its analysis argues that if an ad lacks “story, no music, no character, no joke,” then extra airtime only means “more people ignoring it for longer,” while the ingredients that actually cut through are storytelling, drama, melody, humor, and “fluid devices” such as characters, jingles, and taglines, because ads using them were rated less dull and remembered more often.

That creative advantage is not just anecdotal: on The Agile Brand, Andrew Tindall said Paul Dyson’s work shows creativity is the biggest controllable driver of advertising profitability, with targeting and media choices “far, far below that,” and that emotional, distinctive, entertaining, consistent work explains most campaign outcomes when paired with media choices. Humor is a vivid example of why: Marketing Architects says amusing ads beat flat ones on fame and memorability, while Kantar analysis cited by The Marketing Millennials found humor fell from roughly 55–60% of ads in the 1990s to about 30–35% in 2023, a “big mistake” because it lifts all brand metrics through a halo effect.

Sources
The Marketing ArchitectsThe Agile Brand with Greg Kihlström® | What CMOs Need to Know About Marketing Technology, AI & CXThe Marketing Millennials

Synthetic Audiences Forecast Outcomes

AI-trained on massive, neuroscience-driven datasets now predicts emotional response and sales lift before launch, making pre-testing a credible, data-backed discipline.

What makes these tools newly credible is not generic AI, but trained prediction systems built on large, behavior-linked datasets and used before media money is committed. On The Agile Brand, one testing provider said, “We have this platform called Competitive Edge… to make the mad decision to test every UK and US TV ad as it goes on linear TV with millions of people… we’ve got, you know, a hundred thousand ads tested,” while System1 said its screening model “was trained on System One's database of more than 120,000 ads… which… is 18 million emotional responses.”

The mechanism is emotional quantification: synthetic audiences and neuroscience-derived signals convert likely human reaction into forecastable business outcomes before launch. In the synthetic-audience explainer, they said they worked with “the neuroscience data team” who “started with around 300,000 people that put on these… brain wave trackers… and eye trackers,” and “what you can actually derive from the brain wave signals is… focus,” then introduced “Cortex” as “it allows you to kind of predict what response rates are going to be,” claiming “in our assessments, it’s been 95% accurate because we have pre and post data.”

Sources
The Marketing MillennialsThe Agile Brand with Greg Kihlström® | What CMOs Need to Know About Marketing Technology, AI & CXUncensored CMOGreenbook

Emotional Ads Dominate Leaderboards

System1’s late-2026 rankings reveal that emotionally charged campaigns consistently secure top ratings and commercial upside, especially among supermarket and entertainment brands.

Late-2026 leaderboard results show the market rewarding emotionally strong work with the highest available scores. According to Mumbrella, John Lewis’s Christmas advert reached a 5.6-star rating, while LBB reported that System1’s 2026 early Christmas leaderboard, using data as of November 12, had “eight of the top 12 Christmas campaigns achieving the maximum 5.9-Star Rating,” with Morrisons and Sainsbury’s tied for first and M&S and Aldi also posting the top score, showing that standout emotional performance is clustering at the very top rather than appearing as an occasional outlier.

The same rankings suggest that this reward is broad-based and commercially meaningful, not confined to one advertiser. Ppc News said “Supermarkets take 7 of top 12 places in System1’s early Christmas ad rankings,” while LBB added that grocery retailers were “occupying the top four positions and seven of the 12 places,” and that System1 defines “Star Rating” as predicting long-term brand-building potential and “Spike Rating” as predicting short-term sales potential; the top campaigns combine the “maximum 5.9-Star Rating” with high Spike values, with other major brands including Disney, Barbour and the National Lottery also reaching the maximum 5.9 stars alongside strong upside signals.

Sources

Get the stories behind the trends

Deep-dive reporting and the weekly brief, in your inbox.